cueuianisosaHoi sqeHoi Pag.u [o D\64.051.28 Xapriscrroro saqioualr Horo B.H. Kaparina cururyirvreui yuinep krcz), nr. XaPxin, uafi4an Cso6ogu,6, aYr'.431

BIATvK
HayK' upooecopa, osiqiftnofo orroHeHTa- KaHAI{AaTaIOpIIAIITIHuX 1 Haqio uaJlbHoro IOpI{AHrIHoIo ganiAynaq a naQeAp n quni.ubHo ro up an a J\{b -

-fpoclrana Mylporo irvrerii y"i*.pcnTery EopuconoiBaJreHTrIHrIInaninnu IIaAllcepraqircMelsrruqeHKoIo"uiioleKciisHn Qanrnu Hux run ro6nux <<Marepialblri ra IIp oqecyanHri acIIeKTI{ nPanonigHocl{H)t HayK3a aTalop I{AIITIHIIX ro cTyneHflKaHAIIA noAanoi na s4o6yrrn Hay KoBo qunilrnufi npoUeclcivrefiue cueqia.lsHicrroi2.00.03 - qusi*He rlpaBoi rlp aBo; tuixnapoAne rlprrBarHerlp aBo

yMoBax citu's ArcryansniCft Al{cepTaUifinoroAOcli,qxeHHfl'B cyuaqrux ffi i 6y4rcycliltlctna, xrcttit, i ocnoeHuMocepeAKoM rrepBr{HHr4M 3arrlrruaerbctr sl'IAosluiHroe$c'si xrcuitimuufr cxlaAnufi cOqialrsufi eneueHT'eBoJlrcqionye, sa AiIoquNI cirr',l'i fliACranolo cTBop.HIUI uorpe6ye oxopoHrr na pinHi Aep)KaBI{. se rinsxu 3apeecTposaHlafi vrcpaiuu Bl{3HaeTbcfl .citrefiru,ru 3aKOHOAaBCTBOM a TaKontinrui ni'4Cranu'ue C[OpiAnenHs,yclIHoBJIeHHs', unro6, a ft rqpOBHe
sa6opoueni 3aKOHOM 2 Arre rari, uo He cylepeqaTb MopanbHuM 3acaAaM

- CK Vrp ainra)'T aruv Yxp ainu (.qarri cycnilrcrn a (u.4cr. 3 CivrefinoroKoAeKcy
rrrrHoM, MOX(Ha cTBeppKyBaTr4, rrlo npanoni sopvru civr'i Ha cbor'oAHl

siao 6p Drarorb p isnon'ranirtr nz4in p oAHHII' o puro* nuuepnur'rfr ig ruu rofi fraxr, I]Io Ha pinHi 3aKolryHe BcraHonneHuft
uepelir Citr't'i, He Bu3HaqeHa KoHqenqu 3acTocyBaHHA uigCran CTBOpeHHfl Ha BTIKJMKAS MopaJrbHr{x 3acaA y peryJrrosaHHi UUrO6no-ciuefinnx niAHOCHH, 3oKperrlai uparruqi Uinufi ptA [po6leu, gi norpe6yrors cBoro nupiureuH'l' qrr He nos'.s3aso IIe 3 ne6axanHrlM BI43HaruoAHiero s nianoniAi Ha 3arrlrTaflHs,) MlX XrHKoIo I TaKr4XniACras tparnnvni unrO6ni siAHocI'IHI4,a CAM9niAnocznl'I

y unro6i nrix co6oro, aJIe[on'flgasi cuinrnzvl .rorosirou, xri ue nepe6yBalorb
'a.4 cr. 3 CK oAnierociu'ero? .O4Har, TnyMaqenHs' i upoNltBarorb no6yrorvr

2 xinxrai uotonixa y Yrp aiHu Aae MolKJIrBlcrb crBep4lryBarvl, rrlo 3HaxoA)I(eHHrI
rleBHrrx Saxruunrax u.nro6gnx ni,{uoclaHax upul HaflBnocri AorpI{MaHHt HIIM?I

urnro6i, crBoproe oci6 y 3apeecrpoBaHoMy yMoB,TaK caMosrc i gsaxoA)KeHHr rpyur<qix (pynnqii- peupoAyKrIrBHai s srifi BrrKorryrcrbcfl.nairsaxnusiurifi cirvr'ro, crarefi CK Vrcpaisu- 74 i oKpeMI4x JIpIUe couiarigaqii. MixruM auanisnonor(eHb 3aKoHoAaBeIIb 9I,uacyr;g-4i 5 cr.2tl laenaoxlunicru upufirrlAo BI{cHoBKy,IrIo (p exrant riAnocunn sarruvHoro noApy)Kxt.a rraaftHosi nkrrue orcperrli BpefynboBye a rrpaBoHa yrpI4MaHHs, 3a rrac cninsnoro rrpoxuBar^Hl., vaitua, ua6yroro HLrMrr qoAo iluuoro, ro cittt'i,3acHoBaHina HaycuHonnenru), TaKoxrrpaBo QanruqHI{x uuro6rrrx eirHocvHax 3anuluarorbct s'rcynanur rlo3a cneqiantHoro rlpaBoBoro

perynroBaHHrr. Caue rolry

rlrrraHb IrIoIo

nlarepianbHux i

acuercrisQarruuHux uurc6nI4x rlpaBoeiAHoczHi Aorll'rHrlx Ao rpoqecyaJrbHrrD(
qboro npo6neiu, 3oKpeMasaxpinneHHt[eBHI{x npaBoBux rapaHrifi, xxi neo6xilni sAificHeHru ciuefinux qpaB i nuxonasH.sciMeftHzx o6on'.sgxie AJrrHopMaJrbHoro oco6auu y raKr{x ni4nocnnax, a sarpiuneHrul TaKI4x rapaHTifi i e 3aBAaHruIM raIlift no ro Ao cn iAXeuH.s. JIeHoro ALIcep aAae r uicr up e4cTaB rp aBa,cKJr

He rrpaBoBoroperyJrroBaHHrr flpo6nervu4 Qarcrnunzxurnrc6Hux siAHocI,IH Mox{Ha eiAHecru Ao rrrx, sri He po3nrtAanvc, Ha pinni MoHorpaSiunux npaBoBoro perynroBaHHt Sanruunux AocniAxens. Tax, oxpeui acrreKTr,r .aK n po6orax raKlaxnayronqiB MuIHynoro runro6nux siAHocr.treucsirrroBaJrr.rcfl B.fI. Macnon, O.A. f .K. Marseen, f.I. Mefiep,C.B.flaxuau,f.O.IIIeprueneBr{q, Iyurrin, 3.A. fligoupuropa, Ta cyqacHLIXuayronqir - B.A. Barpac, I.B. XuriHrona, JI.[. Kopomona, JI.B. Kpacuqrxa, JI.B. Jluueqr,

O.L CaSor*rur, I.E. Penyurra, 3.8. Povroncuca, A.O. Oe.rarona-PeAlro,
B acneKrl ue sAiftcurosas B.I. Tpy6a ra in. flpore sixro 3 HayKoBqir AocniAx{eHH.x cr4creMHoroananisy uarepiarbHo-rrpaBoBoro ra rrpoqecyanbHo-[paBoBoro perynroBaHHfl, 4ranauiunocri $axrzuuzx nrrc6Hux siAHocHH3 BpaxyBaHHrrM po3BrrrKyenpoiurerpaqifinux rpoqecin n Yxpaini, nouryKyBaqKa spo6una qe BrrepIue. Ilinuicm roAaHoro Ao 3axlrcry Arrceprarlifinoro AocniAxeHH.s

HtI3KkIHay Ko BI4x i 4 efi , : a) o 6rp ynTyBaHruilvl 6 ararrua qLrHHrrKaMn 3yMo Bnroerbc.rr rrci uoxym 6yru BnKopuc'rauiuplEpospo6qi ni,{nosiAHllx gN{iuao CK Vrp aiuu s

Meroro ycyHeHruriuryrouzx y HboMy rlporanl4H ra rolisift; 6) BI{KopLIcraHruIM HoAaB crBa Boro gop o6ry yrcpaincmoi ra sapy6ixnoi nayrz, ciuefi noro 3aKo HayKo

(Hopnerii, Iclan4ii, folnan4ri, Eenrrii se rinrxu Vqpaiuu,afi zapy6ixnraxrpain
6pauqii, llopryralii, Illnefiqapi, Illneqi, YropIUvYw), a Icuanii, Hirr,reuqI4HLI,
n) onrzuaJIbHLIM

raKox cy4oeoi npaKrr{K}r, BKJrroqaroqui rpaKrl{Ky CCII);

tvtsroAisAocliAxeHH.fl, IIIo cneqianbHo-HayKoBI{x Ha6opou 3araJrbHoHayKoBrlxra nocnyryBano ui,{craBoro Anfl orpuMaHns sricso HoBI{xpBynbrarir, na nup irueHlr.u BI{nIe o3HaqeHnx np o6leu. Ofpanufi Harrp.f,M AocJrlpKeHrur y3roAx(yerbct 3 HarlpflMalolu HayKoBocupxuoBaHlD(

-up Ao cni,qsoi p o 6 oru ra Qe4pu qzsimHo -rrpaBoBrlx AI{cIIHrInin enono iraixo ar oBoro

(farylrrery

3a yHirepcurery ivreni I. I. Me'rHLIroBa OAecrxoro naqionaJrbHoro

ra ueuafiHosiqpaBa oco6u B yMoBaxuo6yAonu rpaeosoi reMaMri: <<Mafinoei n Yrpaiui: npo6nevru ua6yrrx, gAificneHHl ra 3axl{cry)>(gepx(astrufi. Aep)KaBr{ perynroBaHHn peecrparllfinufi HoMep 0108U003958), <<flpunarHorlpaBoBe cycninrnux ni4nocuu: rpa4raqii, cyvauricm, (gepNanHzfi rlepcreKrHBI4>) npaBi gaxoHnuxinrep ecin peecrparlifirmftHoMep 0I 13U002740);<<3a6egnetleHrrrl npo6leuz rlpaBa: y cQepinpI4BarHoro rlo BriHr{Karorb yuacrnriB npaBoBi,Erocun, (4epxasHlafi p eecrpaIIlitsuit HoMep0 118U00 4432). reop ii ra rp aKrI{KH> Cryninr
*

o6rpyuronaHogri

HayKoBrrx rloJro)r(eHb, srcHosnie

i

peKoMeHAauifi, cQoprvrynboBaHrrxy Arlceprallii. 3acnyroeyeHaui4rp I{MKy ra
cxnf,lenns oopaHur4 ArrcepraHToM KoMIIneKcIJuvrrIlAxlA Ao AocnlAx(eHHfl.

fpyuronnufi uayronufi anaris upo6nerra Sarcruuuuxrunro6unxni4uoclrHB
n 4uceprauifittifr KoHreKcri,xx nin npe4craBneHrrfi raKoMy o6c.ssii s raKoNay B yMoBax afi ceoeqacHuM aKryanbHuM, po6oriIO.O. MenrnraqeHKo, eHeJrnrue p ero4ra$iraqii (onouenux) noprvr ciuefinoro rp aBa. p inui r yp axynaHH-aM HacyqacHorvry lncepraqifiHe AocniAxesnsBr{KoHaHo Trrx rrp o6nevl, 3 ypaxyBaHH.sM Airo.rorociuefinoro i qzsinrHoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa roAexcie Vrpailru. sri sraHuKrr.r B yMoBaxoHoBneHHrr I{uninrnoro i Cirvreftsoro

4
rlpaBoBl orry6lirosaHi uarepiam cyAonoi rpaKTuKr4, Anrop ruupoKoBrrKopkrcran Koucruryqifinoro Cyly Vxpaiuu, Bepxonuoro Cy,uy Yrcpafiiu ra BrrcHoBKH pinenr BepxonHoro Cy4y, rrpaBoBinzcHosKuCCIIJI, rlo 3HaqHouiAnLIIIII4JIo 3Mory uomyrynauqi spo6urn 6inrur y3aranbHroroqi 4ocni4xeun-r, AaBrnr4
BI,ICHOBKI4.

repru 3aBce,Merolo r np eAMeroM i o6ynaouleHa, Crpyrrypapo6om BAaJIa rloAlneHvrxHa is ncryny, Tpboxpo3,{rrllB, .4ocnilxenHx.,{ucepraqix cKJraAaerbc-a Ax(epen ra rlorl4pbox uric6 ni4pos,4ilin, nzcuonrin, cwrcKy BrIKopt4craHLIX AoAaryis, lxi BKJrrcqarorbcrrrcoK uy6riraqifi [oluyKyBaqKrr 3a reMolo

fioro p e3ynbrarB. rauifiuoro AocliAxeHH.[ TaeiAol,Iocri np o BrIpoBaAx(eHHl Ar4cep flpu rlboMy uonnufi o6csr AocniAxeHHscKralae24g cropinox. s srcax28 HCTaHLD( CIIIICOKBI4KOp A)Kep en.

Bci

pos.4inra ra

ni4por4inu

3a csoird guicrolra i

sucHoBKaMI4,

noAanbruoro Aocni,qNeunsi nuxopucraHrul An.x po3B}ITKy [epcneKTr{BaMr{ civrefinoro npaBa i garonoAaBcrBay cQepi ciuefinprx siAHocuHn AoKTpr4Hra Yrpaiui cnil Analig i nAaro BI{KJIaAeHkrMvr. Ha3Barrl BaroMr/rMr4 srraicry Arrceprarlii4osnonseAocliArrrr,rrpoqec srineHus iaefi i 4yvrox aBropa s reKcri safi6irlru [epeKoHnuniapryMeHrui nuranHx,xr<i nayxonoi po6oru, Br41rrrlr'rar uorp e6yrorb rloA€ulbrlrllx AocliAxenr. is sN,ricroiuAr,rceprallifinoro AocniAxeHH-sAo3Bon.ge OsnafiovrJreHrur rp n fioro ni4ro ro e qi. 3 n epra e np o cyMJrinnimrs4o6ynauKll spo6urw Br.rcHoBoK Ha ce6e yBary qprcemHicru Br,rKoplrcraHnx 4rrepen (236 uafiiuenynans), Hayronospo6reunx B AucepraqiisucHonlcin. o6rpynryBaHH.f, adbniaxeHr{xAJr.f, TeoperuqHy 6asy AocniANenns cKJrana3HaqHa xirlrricrr yrcpaincrrux i sapy6ixHl,rx BqeHr,rx-qvsiricris ra rtpallb eiAoNarx npaBo3uaellin. 3nricr

po6ir noleperrrurie i aBTopoM AocniANennscei,{rrrrrbnpo rnu6oKe BuBqeH}uI npo6neu, TaK i ix nupiurennxlr. ni4pisuxerrcr sia HHX flK rrocrarroBKoro IrIo lloruyrynaqKa nuie {purrlrqHo oqisronarl{ HayKosi nosuqii s rl4x rIpITaHb, 4ocnigxyrorbcfl, a, nopinHroroqu pisni roqKl4 3opy nayr<onqin,B 6arartox y Al4cKyciis HuIvIu. ra e ronep aHTHoro uosr.rqiro BrrrraAKax $opuymoe BJracHy

5
(c. 21, 4acepraqti; o6'err ra rpeAMer AocuiAxeHH-s BnsHa.ruBrula
aHaJIl3 anropeSep ary), aBTopKa rrocraBHJra 3a Msry rlpoBecrl4 KoMrIJIeKcHvrr4 H.aI.aTvI [paBoBoro peIyJIIOBAHHfl. $alcrnunnx runlo6Hux niAnoczn, a TaKo]K rporro3llqii Uo.qo ycyHeHHJIiqryrouux y 3aKoHoAaBcrBiIIporanIIH ra r<olrgt7' wlpiuenHro KoMrlneKcy flocrasreHa Mera Herc noBnicrro Aocrnryra 3aBAflKLr reoperl4tlneAocniAxeHH.f,icropiicraHoBJreHHr ra npoBeAeHo 3aBAaHb: cKJraAHtrx po3Br4TKy ciuefitrorO 3aKoHgAaebrsa B'IacruHi npaBoBoIO perynloBaHHt

(Qaxruunux runro6nux siAHocI{H) Ha siAHocuH Ao Hprx uuro6nux i upzpiBHrrHt4x repuropiicyqacHoiYrpainu (c.28-52);oxapaKrepu3oBaHolocsiAraoco6lunocri oAsiero citrl'ero xiuxn ra cuinrHoro ilpo)KI4BaHHTI npaBoBoro perynroBanHfi, sapy6ixnux rpain .rorosirca 6eg urnrc6y sa 3aKoHoAaBcrBoM (c. 52-69); B Yxpaini incruryry po3fnrrryro rpaBoBy repcrreKrr/rBy3anpoBaAx(eHHil urnro6y (c. 69 -1 7 ); HarvBr3apeecrpoBarroNly qnninrnoro raprHepcrBaflKansTep Bn3HaqeHo uepelir o6or'sgr<oBr4x eneN{enris rcpIaAI,IqHoro cKJIaAy n.nfl ciu'eto'rorosirca ra xlHKI{ arrHs.oAniero BcraHoBrreHrur Qa*lr cuinruoro rrpoxflrB
6es urnro6y; cfoprr,rylrosaHi ra HeraruBHl4x IrIoAo rIo3I4TI4BHI{X BLTcHoBKI{ oAHlero ilpo)KI4BaHH-fl tbarty cuinuroro ruarepialbHr,rx yMoB Anfl BcraHoBJreHH.f,

ciru'ero.ronosira ra xiuru 6egnmo6y, uagauo eiAuosi4ui nponosnqti 3 Merolo AocriAxeui np oqecyanrnioco6nve ocri yAocKoHaJreHHf, 4irouoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa;
po3rnsAy cy1avtu cnpaB rpo (ba*ty cninrHoro npollfl'IBaHHt BcraHoBJIeHHrI

rrr4Ta[Hfl'Bl4ry olniero ciru'eroqonoeirara xiurul 6esrurro6y, sorcperraanpo6neruni rlpe,{MerysaflBr4(uosony), rrpaBr4lrbHoro cyAoBororrpoBa,eKeHrur, SoprvryrnoBaHHil silicry cyAoBoro piureHnn,qperoArrqifiunxtpanrinroulo; po3Kpl{rrI upo6neuHi B rrpoqecipeanisaqii upana oci6 na Saxrzuui nnro6ni ulo BrrHrrKarorb ukrra11g,
ni4nocznu, snssreHi gar<onoAas.ri rconigii Ta rlporaJlrrHr4, sxi crarorb Ha

neperrrKoli s4ificHeHHrooco6auu csoix rpaB, a6o nasnaKv\ e uiAcrasaNlvr I'nfl' oco6auu 3JroBxfl{BaHHrr ycyHeHrur; rucnirneui HaAaHr4MrIpaBoM Ta HaAaHo rlpono3l4llii uoao oco6rzsocri Ta ronigifini ix

rlaraHH.tt rpaBoBoro

perynroBaHrur xr vrafiHoBr.rx siAHocuH, TaK i niAuocztt, xt<i cKJlaAalomc-s N'Iix .rorosixoM Ta xinxoro, ulo cnilrHo rlpox(LlBarorb oAuiero ciu'ero 6eg urnro6y y

6 inurux . (xuuonifi, cQepax )Kr4Tr cnagrconifi), HaAaHo: upouosvrqii
(c.83-168), xapaKreplrcrl{Ky qpaBoBoro perynroBar^HA rrpaBo3acrocyBaHrur qoroBircona ra xinxoro, xxi cninbHotlp oxl4Barorb ycrlHoBJreHrrrr, ulo sAificHroerbcf, o4niero civr'eto 6es runro6y, 3arrporloHoBaHo rlrJltxu BAocKoHaJIeHHt

cwaq, Als. s qifi c$epi (c. 169-183); rcraHoBJreHoropI4ALIqHuir 3aKoHoAaBcrBa np anoni4HocrrH.rononiroM Ta xinro Hfl. Ta rrp unr,rHennsarirvreHTHlrx BraHr,rKHeH ro,

ciM'ero6es uurro6y,4ocliAx{eHo 3aKoHoAae'ri u1ocninrHo rrpolruBarorbo.qniero

Iursxu ix ycyneHna(c. 183nporanr{Hra Konisiiy qifi cQepi,3arrporroHoBaHo

203).
3asHa.reHi sasAaHrur BlrKoHaui 4ucepraHToM 3a AorloMororo i sasA.sKu gianerrurrHofo, icropuuuoro, cl4creMHo-crpyKTypHoro, nrr,rinol,ry BrrKoptrcraHHro Sopualsno-nori.rHoro, uopinnrlbHo-[paBoBoro Ta ra pflAy iuuux 3araJIbHLIX nignoni4Ho Ao MerI'I i gasAaHr

cueqianrHr/x HayKoBn( MeroAis Aocrigxeuux

. o 6' eKta i up e4llera Ao cniAxeHH.f, nayro noi p o 6orn i s yp axynannsN,I Oqinroroqu o6rpyurosaHicrb HayKoBLIX rIoJIo)KeHb,4zcepraqii, cnig

i upouoauqii rIoJIo)KeHns HaroJrocrrruHaroMy, rrlo B csoifi 6inrurocriBr4cHoBKkt, ]F'iVIMkTi naneXHo o6rpynroBaHwru. e HOBHMr.I, .qOqrOBip Ar4CepraHTKH

[ocronipuicru

nuurosKin i i nonuura HaynoBrrx rroJro]KeHb,

y gncepraqii, y 3HaqHoMy cryueni peKoMeHlauifi, cQoprvry.uboBaHl{x
cyMHinin. flp.aB oBa 3yMoBJrrororbcfl aKTyanbHicrro AocliAxeHHs fi He BI4KJII{Kae

lqo He Mae rrcSarcruqsiuurc6ni eiaHocvrnvl, oqisra raKoro coqialrsoro.flBrlrrrla nprgHa.renocri r SparueHrapHo BperynboBaHo B CK Yrcpaiun, aJIe

po6ora e posfionuoA)KeHo n Vlgauri, uorpe6ye 4ocri4xeHH.fl.flpe4craBJreHa cLrcreMHoro neprxr{M y sirqngusuifi Hayui 4ncepraqifinalr AocniAxeHHrrM perynroBaHHfl ra rrpoqecyanbHo-rrpaBoBoro ananisy naarepiarbHo-rrpaBoBoro 3 BpaxyBaHHrrM Saxruvnzx urnro6nux siAHoczH, flK B)Ke 3a3HaqaJroc.s, 4znauiunocri posBurKy erpoinrerpaqifinux upoqecin r Yxpaini i n iuurux rpaiuax cniry. peyJrbrarin 4uceprauifi soro AocrigxeHHfl . Hayro ra Haynona HoBrr3Ha HoBlr3Ha pesynrrarin AuceprarlifiHoro 4ocni4xenHx, HayKoBrrx oqiuor<,

7 y3araJrbHeHb rporro3r{rlifi i per<orvreHlaUifi, Teoperr,rqHutx ra nucnonxin, .sri cKnaAarorb ocHoBHzfi IO.A. MenrnuqeHKo,3HarrHoro sMicr Ar.rceprarlifiHoipo6oru rraipolo 3yMoBnrcerbcr aKTyaJrbnicrro AocniAxenns. Hayrora HoBrrcHa

i.{xeHH-sN{ Ho Br4 x i Aeit r a Br43 Harr aerbcf, cyq acHoro rtocra HoBro ro np o6neMLr, AocJr po3BlrroK resAesqifi s acnexri reuu Ar,rceprarlii. B podori Aicrann rroAanstnvfir
ronox(eHns iHuvx nayronqiB, a raKo)K cQopuynrosaHi Hoei HayKoBlroJro)KeHH.rr

i nucnoeKu,xr<isauporroHoBaHi anroporr,r oco6rrcro i nuneceni:nasaxucr. Cepe4 rroJro)KeHb HoBr{3Hvr ra) Ha Harrr eJreMeHToM Ar4cepraqii, mi xaparcrepv3yrcTbc.fl IIorJItA, .qorloMaralorbuap iruuru HI{3KyBa)KJrrrBr{x reop erl{qHrrx np o6reu, cnig oKpeMo3yrrr{Hr.rrlr c . HaraKrlx p $yJrbrarax Ao cr iANeH}ur. II o-n epwe, 3acnyroBye Ha cxBaJreHrr.f, i ui4rp zuKy np oBeA asropoM eluuir' aHanisreHe3r,r rrpaBoBr.rxui4crar BrrrHHKHeHux $arruqHllx runro6nzx ei4nocunra
q1e1npooJreMr,r, xapaKTepucTr4Ka xapaKTepucTr4Ka po3pooKtdrllel cyqacHoro cTarry frpo0JreMr{, a caMe Te, rqo y cTarrypo3pooKLt

6imurocri

rqpain yuaurzqr

eC Qaxrnuni urnro6ni ni4noczru.r Marcrb .{iTKo (qzninruufi colo3, AoMaruHe rraprHepcrBo, flKa) Ha

BlrsHaqeHy 3aKoHoM rbopuy nnyrpiurHe naprHepcrBo,

3apeecrpoBaHe rraprHepcrBo rorqo),

ni4uiny nia V4paiun, ruHuKae Ha ni,qcrasi KoHKperHolo rcpr{ArrrrHoro6u*ty (4oronopy, peeqpaqii) Ta lna4aerlirr.rfi KoMrrJreKc oco6ncrr.rxHeMafiuonux ra Naafiuoszx rrpaB,rrprrraMaHHrrx noApyxxrc. Ilo-dpyee, rrosuruBHo Mox(e 6yru oqineno i o6rpynryBaHrur uoAo neAouinrnocri 3asrocoByBaHHt 4o SarrzrrHoro roApyx{xs -.rorosiKara xinnra, u1o[poxruBarorboAnierociu'ero 6es [urro6y, nonrrrr <romy6iHar). fTo-mpeme, cni4 rloroAnTr{cb 3 TrrM, rrlo Ao SarcrrEvnux urnro6nux niguocuH n Vrcpaini uoxe 3acrocoByBarucfl, auarori.s 3aKoHy- t. 2 \. 2 cr. 3 CK Y4paiuu, a rpn yxBaJIeHHicygauu piruenn npo BcraHoBJreHrur (buuty qonosira ra xinxvt o4uiero ciu'ero 6eg runro6y - asanori-s rlpo)KI{BaHHfl crareft 22-26,3941 CK Y4painn rorqo. ffo-qemeepme, nipnoro e upouoszqix siAHocHo neo6xi4nocri

BrIpoBaAx{eHrur iuueparusHoi Br4Morrr rrpo HorapiansHesacni4.reurur AoroBopy, IrIo yKJraAaerbcfl ltix .rorosiroN{ ra xinrcoro,ulo rrpo)KrlB€Irorb oAnierociM' ero 6 es

( a6s. /rcpainz 6n. I4,c.18aerope0.).
V n'flmux, cliA rroroAktr]Ic.fl s o6rpyHTyBaHruIM svrY cyAoBoro

y crrpaBax rrpo BcraHoBJreHHr rrpoBaAXeHHfl $anry rrp oxc4BaHHflo A Hi ero civr' ero

.{oronira

ra

xiuxu

6eg peecrpaqii runro6y ra

uloAo rlporlo3l4qixrr,ru

(uosony) ra suicry p€onrorzsHoi qacrvrHvr rrpeAMera3aflBvr SopuynroBaHHrr cyAoBoro piuennx y cnpaBax rpo BcraHoBJreHrnI Quuty rpoxc4BanHsoAHiero

civr' ero.roroeira ra xinxu 6esurnro6y.
Orpirra rlboro aBTopoM BHeceHo pflr, cnyruHlax, Teoperl4rrHo BAarIo - TaKHx,rqo Mox{yrb 3 a A o Bo JIbHrITH BlI Mo rrr o 6rp yHroBaHrrxi cft op rrayJrboBirHlrx

Ha yAocKoHaJIeHruI crrpf,MoBaHr4x rrpaKTrrKtr, rrporro3u:qiit, Airo.{oro ciuefrnoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa Yrpailrn. 3agua.reHi npouosuqii TaKo)K xapaKrepl,I3yrorbct raqii HoBkI3 Horoi 4onegeuicrro. siAuoeilHoro Anr KaHAr4Aarcmoi Aucep flonnora BrrKJraAy perynrrarin Ar{ceprauifinoro Aoc.nilxeHHfl Ta OcnosHi reoperuuni sHail;ru.ru

HayKoBrrx rroJroxeHb B onyd.nircoBaHr{x[pallflx. ronox(eHrur ir

.axi cQoprvrynrosaHi B 4zcepraqii, ButcHoBKr.r,

ei4o6paNeHrury 31 HayKoBrrxrry6nir<aqixx, cepeA rKr4x

1 xonerrtrBHa

x Y rcpaiuu, 2 uo uorp aSw, 9 warefi y SaxoBax HayKo BIIXnepio4au HLrx Bv LaHH-a inurnx Aep)KaB(oasa 3 flKrrx B crarri y HayKoBux repioAlrrrHux BkrAaHrurx nepio4nuHoMy HayKoBoMy Br,rAaHHi isruzx AeplKaB, .rri nxo4xrb Ao Op rauisaqii rala6oenpoueficbKoro eronouiqHorocninpo6irnlrrlrBarapo3BrrrKy Corcsy), 21 re3ax Aonos iAeir, xrcisacni4.ryrorb arrp06aqirolaarepiarir. Ananis orryt6l iroB aHllx 3Ao6ynaveuHayKo BHXcrareit ra re3 Ao u o s iI efr,na

nffrono-npaKrr{qHuxxouQepeuqi.sx(c. 10-l6auorauii,c.2I-24anrope$epary)
BTTCHOBKy rrpOHanelKrry rroBHoTyBrrKJraAyHayKoBHX rroJrox{eHb, AO3BOnf,e AfirTVr

eucHoerin i pexorraenAaqifi, y Arrcepraqii, n ouy6nir<oBaHr4x c$opnrynboBaHr{x HayKoBrrx IIpausx. ilparcruuna i TeoperuqHa 3Haqulricrn p$yJrbrarin gucepraqifinoro 4oc.ui4xeHHfl. Pesylrrarl,I Aucepraqifinoro .{ocriA}KeHHfl IO.A. Menrnu.reHKoMo)Kyrb y troAanbrrrrlx 6yru BVKoprrcraHi 3araJrbHoreoperlrqHr4x.{ocniAxeHHrx up o6nevr

9 rrpaBoBoro perynroBanns. ciuefinux siAHocLtH;MolKyrb 6yru ni4rpyHrru i rloruyrin i: qiei reuarvrwr: y HayKoBI4x 6asolo An.s rroAaJrbrrrr{x TeoperuqHoro pflAy HopM ciuefinoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa rrpaBorBopvocri - Anfl BperyJrroBaHrur po6ori - Ans uiArorosKz HaBrraJIbHI4x Vrpainz; y HayKoBo-MeroAorori.rHifi uoci6nprris i niapy.rHnxis s rypcin <<I{unirlue qpaBo), "CiuefiHe rpaBo", nilnosi4uux HaBqanbHnx <<I{unirrnzfi upouec) Anr Br.rKJraAaHni 4vrq\unniu;a raKox y rpaBo3acrocosHifi c(fepi i y cQepi rpaKruqHoi Ai-snurocri. Psl xapaKTepi vroxyrr cnyryBarl4 ezcHosrin i uponoguqifi Hocrrb rrocraHoBo.rHzfi o6ronopeur i 4ucnycifi g Merolo rrolxyKy nafirpaulux urn.sxin Anfl rroAaJrbrur{x raHrKoro. nnp iureuru np o6r eu, tri 4o cni4xyn anucfl,Ar4cep
3aynaxeHnr rrloAo srvricry Auceprarlii. PasoN{ 3 Tr4M, rIo3LITtIBHo

oqiHroro.rlr arryanrHicrr

i uayronufi pinenr [poBeAeHoro roxryKyBaqKoro

HayKoByHoBrrrsny, o6rpynronauicrr i Aocronipnicrb, Teoperl4qHy AocriAxeHHrr, Ta rrpaKTr4qHy 3Haquuicrr fioro peeynbrarie An.flnnpiruenruI Marepianrnux ra upoqecyaJrbHux acnelcris {axrravnr,rxurnro6nux [paBoBi4nocnH,peIIeH3oBaHa ra sucHonxie, .axi Mox(yrb 6yru po6ora uicrurr Hlr3Ky HayKoBHX rroJrox(eHb a HelprrHrlruoni froMI4JIKI,I Ile, B ocHoBHoMy, rrpeAMeroM Al4cepraHTa, Ar4cKycii. qu isurux upo6reu,rxi uarcm cnipuufi xapamep. Io fioro BnacHe 6a'reuHfl,Tr.rx Hr4x, Hanexrarb uacryuni: 3O4p eMa Ifo-nepwe, norpe6ye AoAarKonoiapryrvrenraqiiuosuqi-a,ni4nouro .qroi s cyuacrifi Vrpaiui ri4cyrHx coqiamno Kopr{cHa Mera 3aKoHoAaBrroro

p erynroBaHHl^ unro6Hlrx siAuoczH. Qarcruuura>r t uix co6o10 BrrcHoBKr{, ffo-dpyze,clig[orcHrrrrr f,Ky3roA]Kyrorbc.rr Ao .flKlrx rrpr4xo rrorxyKyB aqKa : ArrTb rvrix 1) aBTop HarroJrrraeHa roMy, rqo ni4nocuuu, srci cKJraAanrbc-rr .roroniroM Ta xinxoro, lrlo npoxvBarorb o4nien ciu'eio 6es [ulro6y, uoxna ni4necru Ao cirraefiHr,D(. 3 MoMeHTy Are rarci oco6u cKJraAarotr ciu'ro BrrKJrrorrHo
Ha6pauna saroHHoi cvrilu piruennx cy.4y rpo BcraHoBJreHHrr Sunty npo)KLTBaHH-fl

rrorroBma ra )KtrrKLI rr. 8 c.2I3 o.Ugiero citrr'ero6es [rrro6y (sararbHr BrrcHoBKr{,

p.vrc.;n.8, c. 15anrope(p.).

10
2) pasona 3 Tr.rM,aBTopoM [poBoAr4mc.s iAe.s, trIo B yMoBax cboroAeHHrl BcraHoBJreHHr cyAoM Oatol, nponfl{BaHHfi qorosiKa i xiut<pr oAsiero cin4'ero6es

lpnquHaMrr HeMoxJlzsocri urnn6y ue o6yuoBJreHo 6y.ur-rrznau o6'exrraBHLrMrr rt.2,c. p eecrparlii uurc6y y BcraHoBJreHoMy rropsl6y (sararnui eucHosKLI 3aKoHoM

279tuc.;n.2c. 13anropeQ.).
HaroMy, ulo crami 74 i 91, uacrvnu 4 i 5 cr. 3) ao roro )KaBrop HanoJrf,rae rrpaBoBt4x nacni4xin 2Il 4ircuoro CK VrqpaiHu,xri nepel6a.rarcrs HacraHHrr (nuuurnenns r\dafiHoBax rrpaBTa rpaa ra o6os'.flgrierloAo B3aeMHoro o6os'.sgKie, qoronin ra xinra yrpr{MaHH.fl, KoJrrI rrpaBaHa ycvrnoueuu.r) i e rux BrlrraAKax, [poxnBarorb o.qHiero ciu'ero 6es peecrparlii runrc6y, cni,4unm, Iqo n Vrc.paiHi yMoB An.n na6yrrx vrafiuonvx rpaB ra AoTpr4Maunr6y4b-.f,KtD(QoprraaJlbHr{x a rle niserroe o6os'-f,gKin, xri 4puraMauui no4py)Knco, He e o6os'.flsnoBrrM, iucruryr mmo6y ra 3yMoBJrroe [paBoeufi ruc6ar.auc (saranuri szcHosrcun.4,c. 271 4uc.). flo-mpeme, uorpe6ye AoAarKoeoi apryrueuraqii uosuqia, uoAo

HeMonrJrrrsocri BrrpoBa.eKeHrur r Vrpaiui upanonoroiucrlrryTy 3apeecrpoBaHoro qunimuoro oAHocrareBorora pisuocrareBoro [aprHepcrBa, 3 oAHoro 6oxy, ra HeAocKoHanecynepeqJrr4BeHopMarr4BHeperynroBaHHflni4nocun vrix.{orosixoNr ra xinnoo, rqo qpoxfl{Barorr oAsiero ciu'ero 6es peecrpaqii rurrc6y, s inruoro 6ory, AeMoHcrpyeneo6xiroricrr ni4uoaurzcr ni4 Br.r3HaHHrr 6ygs-nxuxrpaBoBrzrx Hacnigxin uepe6yrasss oci6 y uo4i6noMycoro3 i (cr. 74,9 1, v. u. 4, 5 cr. 21 1 CK
Vrqpainz), 3aJTITuIHBIIIH AaHe coqiamHe sBr{qe rro3a Mex(aMrr rrpaBoBoro
a p erJraMeHTyBaHIIf, IIOp MaMr4 CIMeUHOTO IIp aBa, TOoTO rrp OrrOHyeTbC.fl Br4KrK)r{r4TH3r

svricry CK Vrp aiHz sasHarreHux crarefi ( c. 77 Aarc.,c. anrop e(p. . MiN rI{M, Bl{cJloBnenisaynaxeHrur y cnoifi 6iruurocri e 4ucxyclirtuvu a6o Malorb peKoMeHlautit:auit xapaKTep, ToMyHeBrrJrrrBarorb Ha Br4coKy rro3raTuBHy oqinrcypelleH3oBanoi po6oru n qirorury.34o6ynaqKaHayKoBorocryneHrrIO.O. M enr nu.reHKonon o4 ie AocrarniMz Teoper LrqHvrMvr V, vraeneo6x ilnufi 3HaHHrrM npaxrnluufi 3aKoHoAaBqLIX rroJr0lKeHb,XIO CTALLT AocBl,4 3acTocyBalFIHs.

IrpeAMerouii aocnhxeHHr, BAaJro ananisyenp o 6reuHi uraraHH.s ra Kpraruqso ix

11
sAi6Hicm Ao cavrocrifiHoro BeAeHH.fl 6escyrvrHinny oqiHroe. Boua npo.rrBlrJra Ha HaJIe)KHoMyHayKoBo-reoperl{trHoMy ir HayKoBo-Aocnilnm po6ir p inui. Jlori.nrorr,ry MeroAo o6rpyHroraui reoperzqHi IO. O. MelrHuqeHKo noni HayKoBo Orpurr,raui uayroni np o6neMlas B cyKyrHocri nzpiuryrorb BaxcJltlni pg3ynbrarzi nzuroBKH upaei i s cirvrefiuouy npani, 3oKpeMa.Orxe, 3araJIoM cryuinr HayKoBIIX rroJrox(eHb,s1acHoeKisi pexorraen4aUifi,csoprr'rylboBaHllx y 4Iacepraqii,
My HayKoBoMyp inni. Aocrarnifi . B o nu sp o 6leni Ha HaJIelKHo

.ntricraBr.firbcfl y nonuifi ei4nosi4nocri is nl,IN4oravtu, Po6ora o$oprrrnena MoBoro rcp n.&IrlHoro rp aMorHoro Ao raKoro p ory p o6ir BAK Vxp aiun, HarrvrcaHa
3 BtrKopprcraHlurM npoQecifinoi JreKcHKrr i repnriuonorii, cr?IJIb rIoAaHruI

aBropoMloriwrufi i 4ocrynnufi 4tts.crtpufiutrtx. rvrarepiany 31,ricr arropetfepary noBHorc rvriporo ni4o6paxae cTpyKTypy, xil
AocniAxeHH.f,,ocHosHi norolKeHHr i szcHoeKl4 A?Icepraqii. AnropeSepar He IrIo ne ynifiuulll,4o ocHoBHorostrlicry 4zcep raqti. uicmrr rIoJIo)KeHb,

I4CHOBOK : 3AIA JIb H.TLtrIB
IO.O. MenuruqeHKo 4racepraqifiHa po6ora Ha reMy flpe,4craBJreHa e npaBoBiAnocun> <MarepianrHira rpoqecyarnui acuexru rfaxrnqHrlxunro6HI'IX B .sKoMyorpl{Maur HoBl HayKoBrrM AocuiAxeHrulM, cauocrifiHrrM3aBeprrreHuM HayKoBoro HayKoBoo6rpyuronani pesyrrbrarvr,Iqo cnpfluonani na eupirueHH.a
3aBAaHHrr,.rKe rroJrflrae y po34pllTTi upanonoro urlro6nux
|.

peryJIroBaHHrI Qarruunux i B rlpoqecyarrbHo-

siAHoczH rK B uarepialbHo-rlpaBoBoMy, rar

cirrlefisoronpaBa. s uosuldfi HayKkI acrleKTax rrpaBoBoMy rlopyrueHbaraAevri'rHoi V 4ucepraqii IO.O. Me.ilrnzqeHKoHe Br4flBJIeHo
AO0poqecHocrl.

[ncepraqir IO.O. MenrsuqeHKoHa reMy <Marepianrni ra rlpoqecyalrni acrreKTrd Qarcrn.*rnx runro6nux npanoni4HocrrH))siAuosiAae cneuianurocri npoqec; ciuefiHerpaBo; ivrixnapoAHe 12.00.03_ quninrHe npaBo i qusinrHr,rfi np aBo. rrprrBarHe
BzruaAeHe Br,rrqeAo3BoJrrerpo6uru 3araJrbHl4finrEcuonoK,IIIo sa ceoiNa

'r

l2
3MicroM ra HayKoBoIo HoBI,I3HoIo Al{ceprallifine AocllAxeHlrrl IOnii Onercii'sHra

Memnlr.reHKoHa reMy <MarepianrHi Ta llpoqrciun""i

acrleKrr4 Qarnrrurx

Ilopr.AqyrpucyA)KeHH.fl urlro6nnxnpanoui,qrocuu>nignosi,qaeBlIMoraMu.9r:i:1,1 crynenin, garBep HayKoBrrx AXeHoro rocraHoBoro Ka6iH-sry Minicrp in Vrp ainu si4 24 6unufl. 2013 p. Ne 567, a ftoro aBrop sacnyroBye Ha npucyAx(eHIUI ropuA[trHl,Ix HayK si cueqianrnocri 12.00.03 HayKoBoro cryueurr KarrAr,rnara upLIBarHe upaiib; naixHapoAHe uuninrne ilpaBo i rgsimHprfi [poqec; cirvrefine rrpaBo.

OQiuifiunfi ononenr:
KaHArAar ropHAruHIE( Ha

ralpe4purgmi sani4ynau
H aqioua:rbHororcp u${rl

inreni.flpocnaraMy4poro

ffM

B, I. Eop[coBa

e