2

arpecii nporra VxpaiHu, 3oKpeMa, axrrasHoi 4ix6Hocri cneqclyN6 r<paiuz-arpecopa 3 Merolo .qecra6inisarlii coqianrHo-norirz.ruoi o6craHoBKr4. 4ifi icrorHo 4erepuiHye nepenix o6craeuH, IrIo ni4nxrarorb BcraHoBJreHHro (4orasynanHro) y xpttiuiHanrnoMy tlpoBaAxenui' He szrcraKa€ cyMHiny ft re, rqo xapaKTep 3aBAaHb, xri ezpiruyIorbc'f, criA'rzNa i nporypopovr ui4 qac AocyAoBoro poecri4yBaHHr o6yuonmoe fi ueBHy rlocni4onuicG npoBeAeHH.s
TOBKII

yMoBI4 Tpl4Baloqoi

Taxa pisuonaauirHicG

qilefi

HaBeAeHrax rrporr4rrpaBHlrx

criA'rax (posuryrcoazx) 4ifi, oco6rzsocri ix uiaro-

i upoae4eun-q' Bce ue BKa3ye na Heo6xiAnicrr [epeocMr4cJreH'rr Hr.r3KLr reopeTIIr{HLIX rono}KeHr i crpyxrypHllx eleueHriB MeToAr4Kr{ po3cni4ynaun.a repopr4crr4quux aKris' oripivr roro icHye fi uaralbHa norp e6a y po:po6neHui oHonneHLrx pdrcoueH4aqifi qoAo npoBeAeHHt oKpeMzx cniAvrzx (posruyxoaux)

4ifi, saryreHH-s i nzCarae nvpiureHuro

Kopl{craHHx cneqi€uIbHLIX 3HaHb, 3oKpeMa,

y Sopui eKcleprr4s.

qux npo6JreMH?rx frr.rraHb i upzcnxveHa rrpeAcraBJreHa 4UCepraqix.

llorpi6no

3a3HarrI'ITH,

IrIo o6paHa reMa 4ocni4Nennx ni4uoni4ae crparerii ra
4OCIi4XEH', IIIO cTocyroTbc.rr yAocKoHa_

OKPCMI.IM HANP-'IMKAM PO3BI.TKY HAYKOBI,IX

JIeHHt lcHyloqI4x qI'I po3po6renH-s HoBI4x oKpeMI4x rpzuiHaricrv.rHrax MeTo.rII4K.

cryniHr o6rpyHrosaHocri

HayKoBrrx rroJror(eHb, Br{cnonrcis

qifit cQopMyJrboBaHrrx y Alrceprallii'. Hayrosi noroxeHHr, Br4cHoBKrr i percouen4aqii' c@opMynboBaHi n 4ncepraqii, ni4noni4arorb Br4MoraM Ao raKoro poAy
AXeHb'

i penorueHAa4ocni-

flocrarnro

BIrcoKI4ft pineHr
:

ix o6rpynroBaHocri ra nipori4uocri

sa6egne.{eHi

HaCTyIIHI{MI4 TII,IHHI4 KaMlI

- n qinorray
eJreMeHT

lorivuicrlo

crpyKTypl4 [poBeAeHoro 4ocriAxeHH.rr

opraniuuo [os'.s3aui s inruzuz;

- rcoxHzfi fioro

-

BI{KopI4craHH'[M coliAHoi eunipu'rrroi

i 4Nepemnoi

raqii, 40crarHivr

6asu 3a reMoro ALrcep-

Macr4BoM aHaairzqHux Marepianin;

qilxonuroro eiAnosiAuicrro KoJIa 4ocni4xyBaHr,rx npo6reuHrzx rrr{raHb
upo$inro Hayroroi cneqianrHocri 0g l _ llpano; AocrarHboro rcilrxicfio anpo6aqifi c$opuynboBaHr4x y Ar.rcepraqii rroJroxeHb' Bucuosxin i pexouen4aqifi Ha HayKoBo-rrpaKrr4qHLrx xonsepeuqirx (y r.q. qu-

-

cni rurixHapo4Hux).

Oqinrca svricry Al{cepralliio iT oQoprvr.neHHq

ra

HayKoBa HoBrr3rra Aoc.ni-

Ax(eHHq. Bus.renHx srrlicry .qzceprarlii, osHafioMJreHHir 3 ocHoBHutru rty6nixaqisnara
Aae ui.4craBvr Alrfl. BI{cHoBKy, Iqo

rocrasreHi 3aBAaHHr AocniANeuHx 6ynu nupiureHi, a froro Mera AoctfHyra. Ue gnafiuuo eigo6paNeHHrr B ocHoBHlrx rroJro)KeHHrx, BLrcHoBKax

i

perorvreH4aqixx po6oru, xrci cSopMynboBaHi anropoivr oco6ucro

i

xaparc-

Tepl43yrorbcf, IreBHoro HayKoBoro HoBr,r3Horo ra e AocrarHro o6rpynroBaHlrMlr. Bapro

eiAsHa.{uru safi1\nrrrr BaxJrnsi g Hr,rx.

flo-neprue, AI{cepraHT po3rns.1lae cyrHicm i cnequsir<y repoprrcrrrtrHoro aKTy,
f,K npof,B repopr.r3My

B rpbox acneKrax (posgir 1):

1) coqianrno-uoliru.IHoi xapaKTepvrcrvrKLT,.flx coqianrHo-uoriu{trHor-o flBvrrr\a,
KOJII{

nenHi cy6'ercrz BuKopl{croByrorb i4eoloriro Hacr{JrbcrBa, .f,K zaci6 3€LJr{KyBaHHr{Mr4 rreB-

ux, HalniTaHH.t crpaxy n coqiamHoMy cepeAoBnrqi s ueroro Aoc{rHeHHrr uoi noniruuHoi, i4eonori.rnoi a6o Kopr4cnr4Boi rvrerz;

2) xpuvriH€ulbHo-npaeosoi xapaKTepr4crvrKvr, rK neBHoro cKJraAy 3Jroqr4Hy,
pe46avenoro cr. 258 KK Vr<paiuu;

11e-

3)

r<puvrinanicrn.{Hoi xapaKTeptrcrkrKr TepopLrcrr{qHoro oKTy, sngHa.{eHui

3Haqyqocri

ii

enevreurin (cnoco6in

BTTHHeHH-f,

i

npuxonyBaHH.f,, oco6ucrocri gro.ru-

HII-x, oco6Hcrocri uorepninoro, o6craHoBKr4, xapaKTepHrax

cli4ir), qo

cJryryrorb

rlpeAMerHo-inQopuaqifiHoro ocHoBoro Anr po3po6rcz a4pecoBaHr{x
HayKoBo-MeroAr4rrHr{x peKoMeHAaUtfi
.

cliguifi uparuEqi

B pesynrrari qroro po6umcr o6rpynrosanufi Br{cHoBoK, rqo c$opnaynronani
noJloxeHHx e reoperuqHolo ocHoBoro An[ po3po6reHns MeroAr.rKtr poscni4ysanHt Tepopucrl{rlHoro aKTy, a raKox Marorb cauocrifiHe npaKTraqHe 3HaueHHg Ars cucre-

iuarzaaqii fi aHalisy nzxi4Hoi insopnraqii npo KoHKperHufi repopncrvrqruuir 3aMax,
BrrcyBaHHx
B

fi nepenipxz cni4ql4x Bepcifi, nnpirueHHrr inurux
6escyrr,rHieHlaNa s4o6yrr<oM ALrcepraHTa

3aBAaHb poscni4yeaHHrr

yMoBax KoHKperHoi cniA.{oi curyaqii.

llo-4pyre,

e Br{3HaqeHH-rr rurloszx cni-

AtII4x cHryaqtt, ulo Bl{3Haqarorbcf, Ha{nHicrrc neeHoi inQopNrarlii upo 3jroqr4H:

4

1) Haxnui o3HaKI{ BrIrrHeHHrI Tepopr{crriqHoro aKTy, BcraHoBJreHo oco6y repopkrcra) ;rKoro 3arpr4MaHo B rKocri ni4oaproBaHoro;

2) ncranoBJleHo Qam BqIaHeHH{ Tepoprrcrr4qHoro aKTy, oco6a,
lorrryK;

xrca zpifie1urra

Tepopl4cru'ruuir 3aMax, 3HI4KJIa, €ule e ei4ouocri, Ir1o Ao3BoJr.f,rorb opraHisynarra

if

3)

ncraHoBJIeHo

Saxr BqIlHeHHt repopr4crr.rqHoro aKTy, oco6a, rKa

BqLrHr4Jra

3JIoqLIH 3arllHyna B pe3yJlbrari

nn6yxy (ui4nzury, anapii,3arorureHnx roqo) a6o ni.q

qac np o BeAeHHf, aHTr4repopLr crr{qHoi ouep aqii;

4) ncrauoBJleHo $axr yMLIcHoro sano4ixHH.rr rDKKr4x nacri4xin, npore xapaKrep no4ii, MorLrBr4 ra qini srovnnqin norpe6yrorb .qoAarKonoi cri4.roi nepeniprcrz. ,

[vcepraHr ni4sHa'rae, Iuo niAuoniAHo Ao HaBeAeHr{x cni4uzx curyaryift BucyBalorbc-tr rznoei cniAvi aepcii qo,qo xapaKrepy Mr{HyJroi no4ii, rpr4Hanexnocri ui4o3ploBaHofo Ao repopHcrl'IqHlax QopntynaHb, MorI4nin n.rr4HeHH.f, Tepoplrcrr4qHoro 3aMaxy, MexalrisMy iHiqironaHH.a su6yxy (ni4nary, anapii rorqo), cnoco6ie rtpu26auun
3HapsAb ra saco6iB 3rorrr4Hy rorrlo.

llo-rpere, ui4xpecJlKlerbc.x, ulo BaxirrrBoro yMoBoro eSeruanHoro poscni4yBaHH'I Tepopl{crlltlHoro aKTy e

fioro perenbHa opraHi:aqii,

xr<a rroJrrrae

y creopenHi

H€uIexHLIX yMoB sa6esue'{yB€ulbHoro xapaKTepy, clpsMoBaHprx Ha

peari:aqiro rax-

rl{rlHoro 3aAyMy
HI4IITBa 3

cli4voro. 3nepraerbc.r

yBara Ha Heo6xi4Hicrr ricHoro cninpo6ir-

fpoMaAcrricuo fi

gaco6aNal4 MacoBoi

iusopuaqii Ha rni csoprraoeaHoi o6-

craHoBKH Tepopy, [Il4poKoro

cycnilrHoro pe3oHaHcy ra HeclptlrrrJrrrBoro euorJifiso-

ro craHy y cycninrcrni saranoM. CrsopeHHt raKr4x yMoB aBTop 6atur:t,nepm 3a Bce, y cBoeqacHoMy crBopeHHi cli4'ro-oneparuBHoi rpyurz (COf), xr oguiei s Qopu xoJIeKTHBHOTO MeroAy poscli4yBaHHt, IrIo HaAae Mox{Jrr4sicrr Br.rKopr{cronynaru yci
neo6xiAni cuttu, MeroAI4 i gaco6u
MynboBaHi slaNaorz (upzHqunz)

r ixnrovry

paqioHanbHoMy rroeAHaHHi. Huu csopy3roA)KeHicm rnaHyBaHHx cri4.ro-

4imnocri COf:

po3IIryKoBlIX 3axoAlB; Hepo3ronoureHHt xouSi4eHllifiHoi insopNrarlii (raevrHuqr cni4crna); upiopurer npoqecy€ulbHoro xepinHurlrBa; 6e:uepepsHicrr nsaevro4ii; ilocrifiuuir, cneqianisosanl'Ift xapaKrep 4ixruHocri COf; cra6inrHicrb cKnaAy r{acHr4rcis.

Bzgna.{eHi HacryuHi Sopvru nsaerr,ro4ii

uix

criAqr4Mlr

ra

cninpo6irnzraupr

oreparplBnnx ui4pog.qiris y crna4i COf npu po3cni4yeanni repopucrr,rrrHlrx arrin:

-

cuilrHI,Ifi anaris craHy i Aranavrirrl oneparrannoi o6cranosr<ra, oqinra
BH.aBJIeHI4x

peaJrb-

Hoi He6esIIeKLI

repopr{crur{Hr,rx 3arpo3, a raKox{ yMoB, rr{o cnpurrrom

ix

peani:aqii;

-

y3roA)KeHHf,

cuilruoro

nJIaHy npoBeAeHH-rr opraHisaqifiHHx,

cli4uux (por-

IuyKoBHX),

ueuacsux cliAunx (posrryKoBzx) pliir, TaKT?rqHrrx oneparlifi, o6rono-

peHHs fi. enzna,reHHrl Hafi6inrur e$eruunHrlx croco6is
BaHr{x cni4vo-po3rrryKoBnx :axo4in
;

i

gaco6in peanisaqii 3arrJraHo-

-

ctrpvrfl]F'Hx

cli4uoMy y npoBe.qeHni orna4y vricqx repoplrcrnqHoi utaKvr, BLr-

piureHHx opraHisaqifinux [I{TaHb rrloAo oxopoHLr rraicqx 3roqvuy, BraKopncraHHt

cnyx6ono-po3lxyKoslax co6ax, iHunrx oneparr4BHo-po3rrryKoBnx saxo4in sa6esneqeHH,f, KpHMlHarrbHOfO npoBaAXeHH_rr;

-

BI4KoHaHHt oleparLrBHuv'Lr npaqinHuKaMr4 rrlrcbMoBlrx AopyqeHs

cli4uoro

n

noprAKy cr., cr. 40,41,246 K|IK Yr<paiHra;

- r4ificueHH.a

3a IrLIcbMoBI4M AopyqeHH.trM

cli4voro

po3rrryKy oci6, [pnrrerHr4x

,4o BTTHHeHH-I repopncrllqHoro aKry

(". 3 cr. 281 KIIK Yrcpainn), roruyK rana-ris
Vrpainu;

nepeHanpaBJleHH.f, ui4ospronaHl4x oci6 .repe3 AepxaBHzfi r<opAon

-

cnpl{rHns criA.roMy y

BIaqBJreHHi

o.reszlqin ar<ry repoprzr3My, s4ificHeHrur
3Jrorrr4Hy,

noKBaprLIpHrIX

ta uo4nipnux o6xo4in n pafioni vricqa

orrrryBannx upaqin-

uutcis ui4upueucrB, ycraHoB Ta opraHisaqifi, poera[roBaHux no6nra:y 6eauocepe4Hbofo o6' erra repopi4crl4r{Hofo 3aMaxy;

-

HaAaHHx repinHprx :aacraHoB

ra KoHcynbraqifinoi AorroMoru cninpo6iruu-

KaM, 6esnocepeAHbo :a4ixulEvr
oKpeMHX

y cuimHux onepaqirx, raKTrlqHlrx xou6isaqilx,
r1e-

cliAqnx ra opranisaqifiHHx 3axoAax;
[poBeAeHHt raKTLIuHr4x oleparlifi, cupxuoBaHr4x Ha ycyHeHHr

- cuilrne -

pe46a.rynanoi repopr4crr.rqHoi sarposr,r;
BI{KopI{craHH-q cJrlArIIrM orreparr{BHo-po3ruyr<osoi iu$opnaaqii, uarepianie

oreparl{BHo-po3rrryKoBl{x o6nixie ilpo repopzcrzuHi opraHi:aqii, xrci craHoBJrrrb 3a-

rpo3y 4epxani.

6

llo-'rereepre, 3HaqHa yBara rpz4inena BZ3HaqeHHro poni nernacHzx criA.rrax (posuryxonrax) Aifi (HCPA) npu poscni,4ynaHni repopr4crzqHoro aKry. Big:na.raeru-

c{' ulo OAHI{M is KnIo'IoBux
uicqr
o6cssi

raKTIzIqHr4x 3aB.qaHb poscni4yBaHH.fl

€

BcraHoBJreHH-f,

MoxJILIBoro 3HaxoA)KeHH.a scix cuisyracnurciB 3roqnHy, BaB.leHHt B rIoBHoMy

ix oco6zctoctefi, poAI,IHHI4x,

Apy)KHix

ra

3rorruHHl4x gs'ggrin, s'rcyraHH;r 3a Aolol,rororo HCPA nepenipx-

MorusallifiHoi ocHoBI{ ra Meru

BrII4HeHH.s 3nor{r.rHy.

erbc-{ npTIHELJIe}KnicE ui4o:pronaHoro ,qo rpyn qr4 opraHisarlifi repopr{crn.rHoi a6o

excrpeuicrcrxoi cnpf,MoBaHocri, Bl{tBJl-f,rorrcg saco6rr Brrr4HeHH.rr 3rorrr4Hy, npe.qMeTrr ra AoKyMeHTu, xxi BKa3ylorb sa oco6ucricm 3JroqlrHrlt, a raKox inrua .rIOKa3oBa
ra iHrua in$oprvraqix,
uqo Mae 3HarreHH{ AJr-{ rpzvrinanbHoro npoBaAXeHHr.

[HcepraHToM Ha ocnosi aHanisy quHHoro rrpaBoBoro perynnBaHHrr npoBe-

HCPA ra rlpaKTlarcu fioro 3acrocyBaHHrr rporoHyerbc-rr Ha 3aKoHo4anvouy pirHi nepe46a\uru npaBo oreparlrBHl4x npaqienurdn iniqironarkr [poBeAeHHfl KoHKpeAeHHf,

ra 3Beprarncfl 3 ni4noni4ur4M KJroloraHH.flM npo ix rpoBeAeHux 4o criAqoro rII4 [poKypopa i TuM caMr4u 6parz aKTr{BHy yrracrb n ix ni4rorosqi Ta no.rla_
rHI4x HCPA

mruoi opraHisaqii.

flo-n'.sre,
eKcrrepTr43:

Ba)KJIIIBI4M e BI43HarreHH.s

oco6rzsocrefi ni4roronrz

i

nponeAeHHf,

- nn6yxo-rexni'rHoi ercnepruau (excnepru3a ua6lxonux nprrcrpoie, cni4in ra o6crasHH eu6y><y, eKcneprusa nu6yxoBux peqoBlrH, upo4yrrin nz6yxy ra nocrpi-

ry); - eKcneprzsz s6poi ra cd4in u nur<opl{craHHr (cy4ono-6aricrz.rHa
sa); eKcrreprr4-

- cyAoBo-MeAHqHr4X eK0nepTr{3; - r<puuiHanicru.rHi eKcrreprLr3r4 AoKyMeHrie ra iH..

CSopuynroeaui ALIcepraHroM IroJrolr{eHHfl i pexouenaaqii ni4o6paNa}orb cnequ0ixy 3aB.4aHb eKcneprHlEx 4ocri4xeHb npr.r AocyAoBoMy poscri4ynanHi repopl4crl4rlHoro aKTy' e AocrITb 3HaqyIquMI{ - BkIcHoBKI{ ercueprin Aosori qacro e KJrroqoBr4Mr,r B Cr.rcreMi

40ra":in si cropoHu o6nuHyBalreHHs.

7

flosHora
KoBrrx

Br{KJraAy

ocHoBHr{X rroJro}r(eHb AUCepraqii

B

OUy6.nircoBaHr.rx

rrparlflx. OcnosHi nayrosi froJroxeHn.q i

sracnoBKLr Ar4ceprarlii nzr<na4eno

y 3 Hay-

crarrrx, ony6lir<oBaHrlx y Saxonux BI{AaHH.rrx, nepeJrir xxzx 3arBepA)KeHo MiuicrepcrBoM ocsirz i uayr<z VxpaiHu, a raKox n 1-fi crarri, ony6nir<onanifi y 3apy6iNuonay SaxonoMy BI'IAaHni, npoiuAeKcoBaHoMy

B 6azi gauux Web of

Science

Core Collection, B re3ax 4 AouosiA efi na HayKoBo-npaKrr4qHnx r<oH6epeHqixx. Kinrr<icrr, o6csr ra sN'Iicr ApyKoBaHI{x rparlb ei4noni4alorb Br4Morau MOH yrcpaiurz IrIoAo ny6nir<aqifi ourosHoro evricry Ar4ceprarlii na

:4o6y1x

HayKoBoro cryrreHf,

AoKropa SinocoQii i Ha4arorb aBropoai npano ny6ri.ruoro 3axr4cry 4r.rcepraqii. Irparcru'rHe 3HaqenHn po6oru. Bzxna4eni B Azcepraqii nzcnoBKr{ fr npouogvqii Mo)Kyrb 6yru nuropzcrani:

- B rrpaKTu.{Hoi

4itlruocri

rrpaBooxopoHHt4x .1iau. BI4.SBJICHH' vIJr onr.cr urA rI1A qac: l-vururl\ opranin SI4xlJJleHH, I po_

3cJIlAyBaHHt aKTrB Tepopkr3My; rrpoBeAeHns criA.rrzx (po:ruyxonux), HerJracHr4x cli_

ffII'IX (po:uryxonnx) aifi na pisuux craAixx xpzuiHarbHoro rpoBaAXeHHx; ri4roroBxu i upoaeAeHHq cyAoBlrx eKcneprrr3;

- B npaBornopvifi Ai-sruHocri

-

4nx BAocKoHzureHH-{ 3aKoHoAaBcrBa i niaoNr.{Hx

HopMarrrBHo-npaBosux axris y c$epi nporra4ii repoprl3My;

-

B HaBq€LlbHo-Mero.qv'rHifi

po6ori

- An.a ui4roronKr4 HaBq€ubHr{x

noci6'ur<is.

MeroALIqHI{x po3po6orc ra 6esnocepe.qHbo B HaBqaJrbHoMy npoqeci, 3oKpeMa upn BrrKnaAaHHt Kypcy <<Kpzrvrina-nicrura>>.

3aynaxeHHs ra 4ncrcycifiHi no.noxeHHfl suicry Ar{ceprarlii. B qiroMy AurcepraqifiHe rocliAxeHHs e4ificHeHo Ha AocrarHbo Br{coKoMy HayKoBoreoperl4qHoMy pinni.

llpore, ocrilrxu Aesxi ftoro noJroxeHHr € racKycifiHuulr, qo
ra

tloe's3auo 3 ro3HarIeHHtM aBTopoM sracHoi uosuqii rloAo oKpeMrrx 4oc.ui4NyBaH'x npo6leuuux rII'TaHb, Bapro spo6uru nesHi 3ayBaxeHH.rr, yroqHeHH.s
peKoMeHAa-

qii s vrerolo

yAocKoH€uIeHHt oKpeMI4x Br4KnaAeHr{x lono)Kesr. ocHoaHi saynaxeHH.'

3BOI.rrTbcr Ao HacTyfrHofo.

1'

flpn anarisi raKoro eneMeHry

rcpzvriHanicrz.rHoi xapaKTep LrcrnKr4Tepopr4c-

TrlrrHoro aKTy, rK THrroBi cnoco6ra fioro Bqr4HeHHtr, AncepraHr (c. 66_67) nigHocurr Ao HHX :4ificnenHx xi6eparaxu (uaua4 Ha KoMr'rorepni rala6o reneKoMyniraqifiHi

Mepexi). V :n'xsxy 3 rIr4M BLrHr4Kae rrLrraHHs. npo ni4rrainui pucra repopr43My ni4 iH_ rur.rx 3Jrorrzuin upz uo4i6Hoiray cnoco6i Ait 3JroBMr4cHzxin. r{z uorpe6yerrc.a ryr
rna;riQixar{is sa rcinrroua crarrrMr4 KK VxpaiHa?

2'

Y 4ncepraqii, xtt orpeui crpyKTypui

ererraeurr{ Merorr4Kra po3cni4ynaHnx

BI{3HaqeHi <<xpzrraiuanicrpt'rHa xapaKTepl4cruKa Tepopr4crr4qHoro aKTy) Hz, xr<i niAnflarotr s'.acynaHHlo tlpr{ po3cri4ynaHHi Kae III4TaHH-g npo

ra

<<o6crasr4-

repopzcraqHoro aKTy). Buru-

ix

cninni4HolrleHH.a, trpo trlo rroBLIHno

6yru, flK Bpr;'aerbcr,

3iBHa-

qeHo n 4ucepraqii.

3' B 4acepraqii BI{3HaqeHi rzuosi crilqi caryaqii, u1o cnpufiMarorbc.s.sK nocrarHbo o64pynroeaui' B rofi xe qac curyagix J\b4 <BcraHoBJreHo @ap yuzcHdro 3arIoAl'{HH'[ TDKKI4x nacli4tcin, npore xapaKTep no4ii, MorLrBr{ ra qini srovuHqiB rrorpe6yrorr Ao,{arKoBoi cli4voi nepeniprro> (c. 109) avrcnr{Kae 3arr,nraHH.tr. gv e ue BI4TIaAKOM' KOJILI ni4cyrni o3HaKI{ Tepopncrr4rrHoro aKTy Ha MoMeHr ni4xpurrx KpLrrraiHalrsoro rIpoBaAxeHH-{? -flr<u1o raK, To .sxi calae o3HaKa ryr e Hafi6inrur 3HaqyIrII{MI4' IrIo Ao3BoJIte KBErlliSixynaru ganoAi.sHHt rf,xKrax HacniAxin caue rK TepaKT Ha rror{aTKy AocyloBoro po:cni4yn auns?

4' Y suc'roBKax Al'cepraqii (9 i 10) aa:Hav aerbcfl, rrlo Ar.rcepraHroM 3arrponoHoBaHo AonoBHI{Tu 'luuHr4fr KIIK Vrpainz, ale caui AorroBHeHH.rr He HaBoA-trTbcr, xoqa y rercri Al'Icepral{ii soHz uane4eui. Bz4aemc{, trIo qi
nponoszqii e npr{Hru4rloBo tsoKJrl4Bl4tvrv

i nosaHui 6ynra suafrrkrcBoe ni4o6paNeHH.f, y Br4cHoBKax.

BurnaAeui sayraxeHHs i uo6aNanH-rr He flprrMeHrrryroTb 3ar€urbnoi 4ocvrb Bnncoxoi oqiuxrz pienro BI{KoHaHHt Al4ceprarlifiHoi po6orz, ii reoperu.rHoi qiHHocri ra rpaKrr4qnoi suavyuqocri.
3ara.rrsHi BrrcHoBKrr
: AzrMkrpa

1' {zcepraqix llouosa Boro
Tepopr{cTr{rrHofo aKTy>

lopifionz.{a (Mero rLrcapo:cni4yaaHHrr
HayKoBOrO

e 3aBepueHoro caNaocrifiHoro KB€rJri$iKar{ifiHOrO

rrparlero, s sKifi s ypaxyBaHH-rrM oHoBJreHofo xpzuinanbHoro i xpzvriuarbHoro rpo_ qecyanbHoro 3aKoHoraBcrBa YrpaiHz, c0opnaynboBaHo ra o6lpynroBaHo Hr43Ky re-

oper[rrHux rroJroxeur
qeHH.f, poscni4yBaHHrr

i

npaKTnrrHux peKoMeHAaqifi

qolo

MeroAr4qHoro sa6esne_

repoplrcrrrqurlx aKris.

o

2. C$opuylroeaui B Ancepraqii nracnoBKr4 i nponosuqii rr,rarorb reoperr4.rge i
lpaKTI{rIHe 3HaqeHHt, .f,Ke IroJrrrae B ToMy, rqo pe3ynbrarr{ Auceprauifinoro AocniA)KeHH-rr

Mo)Kyrb

6yru nuropucraHi

:

- B npaKTz.rHoi Aisnrnocri upanooxopoHHlrx opraHin ui4 .rac:

Br.r.f,BJreHHx

i po_

:cni4yaaHu.s axrin repoprl3My; npoBeAeHHr criA.rux (posruyxonax), HerJracHr4x cni.qqkIx
KH
1

(posuyrorux) 4ifi
- B npaBornopuifi

Ha

pisuzx cra4ixx xpuviHanbHoro rpoBapKeHH.rr; ni4roron-

npOBeAeHHr CyAOBHX eKorrepTr43;

4irlruocri -

4na BAocKoHaJreHH-f, 3aKoHo.rlaBcrBa

1 BI,IIOMIII4X

HopMarr4BHo-npaBosr,rx aKrie

y c$epi nporz4ii repopr43My; po6ori

-

B HayKoeifi

i

HaBq€uIbHo-MeroAI4.IHifi

- [nfl ni4roronrra

HaBrraJrbrirr{x

noci6uuxin, uero4l{qHl4x po:po6ox ra 6esuocepeAHbo B HaBrraJrbrroMy upoqeci, :oxpeMa npr4 BuKna.qanHi Kypcy <Kpnrrainani cruxa>>.

3.

[vcepral{ir

((MeroAI4Ka poscni4ynaHHrr repoprrcrr4qHoro aKry) ni4noni4ae

4orropa Sinoco$ii, 3arBepAxeHoro rlocraHoBoro Ka6iHery Minicrpiu Yrcpailly ei4 6 6epesnx 2019 p. Js 167, ButvtoraM 4o oSopnaJIeHHr Ar.rceprarlii, sarnepA)KeHr4M Har<asola Minicrepcrna ocniru i nayxu vxpaiHra
J\lb

Br{MoraM llopx4rcy rpoBeAeHHf, eKcnepr4MeHry 3 rplrcy,exeHHr cryrreHf,

40 rlit 12 ci.rHq 2017 poKy, a iT anrop

-

IIo-

noe Boro rLrwvrp Iopifionurr - 3acnyroBye Ha rrpucyA)KeHHs cryueH.rr AoKropa Sinoco$ii sa cleqialruicuo 081 - llpano.

OQiqifiuufi ououeHr:

llpoSecop rca$e4pz
r(pr4.M rcpznaiHanbHofo r H aJ I bH or'()

npoqecy rlp oqe cy Ta Kp KpLrMlH€L[lCTr4KH LIM1H€UI1 CTI4KH

{oHeqrxoro ropr.rAr{qHoro incruryry MB C VxpaiHra

AoKTopIopI4AI4qHI4XHayK'npo$ecopffiA.@.Bolo6yen

\::4

fli4uac npo$ecopa Bono6yeea A.@. :acei4uyro: a (

lff_
d

/